Wishes & Dreams by Wild Magic of England

The magician displays two tokens, one a heart and the other a star.

In full view on the table is a closed plastic wallet. Two spectators select a card each and place them face down on the table without looking at them or letting the magician see.
The spectators then select a token each and place it on top of their card, swapping tokens if they prefer. The magician opens the wallet and takes out two playing cards. One of the cards has a cut out of a star and the other of a heart. The spectators are asked to turn over their selections and are amazed to find that not only do their cards match those of the magician but that the token they selected matches the cut out on the magician's prediction!

Instructions included.